Welcome to Pie In the Sky
Located at 105 Duncan St C in Lancaster, PA, Pie In the Sky is a beloved local eatery that promises delightful meals in a warm, welcoming atmosphere. Customers rave about the generous portions and outstanding flavors, with standout dishes like their meat lover's stromboli, cheesesteaks, and garlic knots. The friendly staff and quick service elevate the dining experience, making it a must-visit for anyone in the area. Whether you're fueling up after a hike or enjoying a casual meal, Pie In the Sky offers great value without compromising taste. This gem is a testament to community and culinary passion.
Pie In the Sky: Reviews & Ratings
Awesome restaurant!! Got a meat lover's stromboli, a cheese steak special and a tossed salad. Best we've ever had! Owner was very nice. Friendly to everyone that came in.
The family was very kind and service was great.
What a great find. Out on a hike and built up an appetite and found PIE IN THE SKY. A godsend. Great service - FAST AND FRIENDLY. Superb prices. Huge portions. The staff are very friendly. You gotta try these guys out. You will be glad you did. We had cheese fries, wings, and a meatball sub. Gonna try more next time. We’ll be back!!!
I’ve passed this place a few times and finally decided to give it a try. It’s hard to beat a place that puts out a solid product for a cheap price. For under 25, we got a dozen garlic knots, a one-topping slice of pizza and a foot long sub with three types of meat. The knots were generously doused in butter, garlic and topped with parm cheese. The sub also lasted two meals for me. Check this place out.
Great food. I mean... GREAT. Staff is very nice. Had our order done quickly and cooked perfectly.
Had just finished a session at the gym. Ordered a Pizza Cheesesteak to go. Gentleman at the counter was on top of things. The cheesesteak was ooozing with lots of cheese folded into a generous portion of meat. The right amount of sauce. 11/10 for only paying 10, would recommend.
Pie in the Sky did the catering for my daughter's baby shower in May of 2025. From my 1st telephone call with the owner and the subsequent calls with the manager, the service was friendly, professional, and very accommodating! The food was on time, made with care, and absolutely mouth-watering delicious. As the Grandmom to be, I was thrilled that we decided to use Pie in the Sky for this event. I would highly recommend. Thanks Guys!!
Grew up down the road been coming here since they opened In like 2010 I think it was... owners paid for my stuff at turkey hill twice and i never asked for it. And they have never made a mistake on any order of mine. The food is great too. The cicilan is fire. Prices are affordable
Location
-
Ground Floor, 105 Duncan St C, Lancaster, PA 17602, United States Hotline: +1 717-390-0900
Welcome to Pie In the Sky, a delightful culinary gem located on the vibrant Ground Floor of 105 Duncan St C in Lancaster, PA. This quirky eatery has quickly captured the hearts—and appetites—of locals and visitors alike. Known for its comforting and hearty offerings, Pie In the Sky is not just another restaurant; it's a haven for food lovers seeking generous portions and unbeatable prices.
One step inside and you’ll be embraced by the warm, inviting atmosphere. The friendly staff complements the cozy setting, ensuring that you feel right at home as you embark on your culinary adventure. Glancing at the menu, you’re greeted with an array of mouth-watering options, from their tantalizing meat lover's stromboli and delectable cheese steak specials, to those irresistible garlic knots drenched in butter and garlic, sprinkled with parmesan cheese. Every bite is a reminder of why this restaurant is a standout.
Customer reviews echo the sentiment of the delightful food and stellar service. Tracy Mitchell praises the stromboli and salad, calling them the best she's ever had. Meanwhile, Ira Steele highlights the kindness and attentiveness of the family-driven staff, who goes above and beyond to make each dining experience memorable. It’s evident that Pie In the Sky isn’t just about the food; it's about creating connections too.
If you’re looking for a quick bite post-hike, Tom Johnson-Medland’s experience perfectly encapsulates the spontaneity and satisfaction of dining here. He stumbled upon this eatery, and it became a godsend with its fast and friendly service along with sizable portions of cheese fries and wings. Each dish leaves a lasting impression, making it hard to resist coming back for more.
In my own tasting journey at Pie In the Sky, I couldn’t help but revel in the sheer joy of their foot-long sub loaded with three types of meat. It not only was a feast for my taste buds but also seemed like a great value that easily could feed multiple meals. The atmosphere, paired with their culinary creations, makes every visit a flavorful experience.
So if you find yourself in Lancaster, treat yourself to Pie In the Sky. With their incredible food, attentive service, and a community-focused ambiance, you’ll feel like a part of the family—and you just might leave with a new favorite dish.